Experienced Legal Defense You Can Trust - Protect Your Future Today

Criminal Defense Lawyer Spartanburg, SC

Criminal Defense Lawyer Near Me Spartanburg, SC

Facing criminal charges Near Me Spartanburg, SC can be a deeply traumatic experience, with even minor offenses having a significant impact on an individual's personal and professional life. The consequences of a criminal record can be severe, resulting in job loss, loss of friendships, and even estrangement from family. For many, the only hope of leading a normal life is to have a skilled criminal defense lawyer Near Me Spartanburg, SC, fighting for their rights from the outset of legal proceedings.

This is where Lauren Taylor Law comes in, offering hope and proficient legal representation to those who need it most. Our criminal defense team was established specifically to help hardworking people who are facing a difficult road ahead due to criminal charges. With years of experience and deep knowledge in the field, we are committed to ensuring our clients maintain their freedom, so they can move forward with their lives and provide for their families.

We have extensive experience in handling all types of criminal cases Near Me Spartanburg, SC, from run-of-the-mill DUI charges to more nuanced cases involving juvenile offenses. Unlike other criminal defense law firms, we take a personalized approach to every case, utilizing cutting-edge legal strategies and innovative technologies to ensure the best possible outcomes for our clients.

Abbeville Attorney Spartanburg, SC

Some of the most common cases that our lawyers work with include the following:

  • Misdemeanor Cases
  • DUI Cases
  • Burglary Cases
  • Domestic Violence Cases
  • Juvenile Crime Cases
  • Theft Cases
  • Violent Crime Cases
  • Weapons Charges Cases
  • Shoplifting Cases
  • Many More

Selecting the best criminal defense lawyer for your case in South Carolina often means the difference between freedom and conviction. When your future is on the line, contact Lauren Taylor Law to work with a fierce advocate willing to fight for your rights. Of course, when you've been charged with a crime, having extra knowledge about South Carolina law can go a long way. Before we touch on some of our specialties, it's important for you to understand the various types of criminal defense cases in South Carolina.

What Type of Criminal Defense Do You Need in South Carolina?

cd-head-bottom

Criminal cases in South Carolina are broken down into a few different categories. As a very general rule, crimes that are punishable by three years or less are considered misdemeanors in South Carolina. Anything punishable by more than three years in prison is usually classified as a felony.

Legal Defense Spartanburg, SC

Federal and State Cases

Crimes can be classified as either state crimes or federal crimes, depending on whether they violate state laws or federal laws. The decision on which category to pursue charges under is typically made by the prosecutor. Generally speaking, crimes such as assault, robbery, domestic violence, theft, and rape are considered state crimes. Federal crimes, on the other hand, may include computer crime, major drug trafficking, hate crimes, and money laundering, which are often handled by agencies like the FBI or IRS.

Criminal Charges Spartanburg, SC

Plea Deals

It's common for cases to be resolved outside of court. A plea deal allows the defendant to admit guilt to one or more charges without having to go through the trial process. In fact, your criminal defense attorney Near Me Spartanburg, SC, and the prosecutor of your case work together to reach a mutually agreeable deal, to avoid the risks and unpredictability of a trial. By taking a plea deal, you may receive a reduced sentence and avoid the stress of a full-blown legal battle.

Misdemeanor vs. Felony Cases in South Carolina

For the average person charged with their first crime, understanding the difference between a misdemeanor crime and a felony crime can be hard to grasp. In simple terms, misdemeanors are usually considered petty crimes. They often result in fines and can involve time already served at a local county jail. Trials and plea deals for such offenses often move quickly due to their nature.

On the other hand, felonies are much more serious crimes that are classified by degrees. The most severe of these are first-degree felonies, while the least serious are sixth-degree felonies. When someone is charged with a felony, they may face hefty fines and a prison sentence of over a year in a federal or state institution. Those who have been convicted of a felony may encounter difficulties after their release, which is why it's crucial to have a reliable criminal defense attorney.

Legal Representation Spartanburg, SC
Court Defense Spartanburg, SC

SC Code Section 16-1-20 provides us with a helpful penalty outline as it relates to felonies and misdemeanors:

  • For a Class A felony, the maximum sentence is 30 years.
  • For a Class B felony, the maximum sentence is 25 years.
  • For a Class C felony, the maximum sentence is 20 years.
  • For a Class D felony, the maximum sentence is 15 years.
  • For a Class E felony, the maximum sentence is 10 years.
  • For a Class F felony, the maximum sentence is 5 years.
  • For a Class A misdemeanor, the maximum sentence is 3 years.
  • For a Class B misdemeanor, the maximum sentence is 2 years.
  • For a Class C misdemeanor, the maximum sentence is 1 year.

It's important to note that these are maximum sentences, and the actual sentence may be less depending on the specific circumstances of the crime.

Why Hire a Criminal Defense Attorney Near Me Spartanburg, SC?

cd-head-bottom

Hiring a criminal defense lawyer is a serious decision that should not be delayed. The longer you wait, the fewer opportunities you have for a positive outcome, as the penalties, fines, and potential jail time can increase. It's important to seek counsel from experienced criminal law attorneys, like Lauren Taylor Law, to protect your career, family, and personal freedom. When you work with our criminal defense law firm in South Carolina, you can rest easy knowing we:

Abbeville Law Firm Spartanburg, SC
  • Instigate a pre-trial investigation covering involved parties, police, witnesses, and more
  • Secure expert witnesses to testify on your behalf, such as private investigators, doctors, polygraphists, and more
  • Examine and evaluate the evidence against you to ensure it was collected in a legal manner

Here are just a few reasons you should hire a seasoned attorney if you've been charged with a crime in South Carolina:

Deep Understanding of the South Carolina Judicial System

Hiring a skilled criminal defense lawyer is crucial for many reasons, one of which is their understanding of the complex judicial system. The legal system can be difficult to navigate, even for those who work within it frequently.

But with a proficient defense lawyer on your side, you'll have a personal guide through the process specific to your criminal case in South Carolina. At Lauren Taylor Law, we believe in demystifying the judicial process by providing one-on-one counsel and a comprehensive explanation of South Carolina court proceedings when needed.

Criminal Justice Spartanburg, SC
Legal Rights Spartanburg, SC

Have Your Best Interests at Heart

When you work with Lauren Taylor Law, you're being represented by a team of hardworking, client-first advocates who aren't afraid to fight for your rights. That's very important in the world of criminal law, where lawyers and other parties may try to fool you into saying or doing something to jeopardize your case. From your initial consultation to the time your case is closed, your criminal defense attorney Near Me Spartanburg, SC, should always prioritize your best interests and advise you on how to proceed in your case.

Fight for a Fair Future

If you are facing criminal charges, a skilled defense attorney can advocate for you and work to secure a better outcome. They may be able to negotiate reduced charges or penalties or even have your case dismissed if the police obtained evidence illegally.

This can prevent a felony conviction from tarnishing your record and causing harm to your current or future career. Additionally, a reduction in penalties can help you avoid jail time and hold onto your job. Ultimately, a dismissal of your case can spare you from a life in the legal system and help you secure a better future for yourself and your family.

Defense Attorney Spartanburg, SC
Criminal Defense Lawyer Spartanburg, SC

Prosecutor Relationships

At Lauren Taylor Law, our criminal defense attorneys have decades of combined experience. We've seen and done just about all there is to do in terms of criminal defense in South Carolina. Along the way, we've developed relationships with local prosecutors that help us obtain desirable results for clients. Establishing a cordial rapport with an "opponent" may seem strange, but it benefits both sides as familiarity breeds a more pleasant experience.

A skilled lawyer who has cultivated a positive relationship with your prosecutor can significantly impact the verdict of your case. Through their amicable ties, they may secure a favorable plea bargain or negotiate a reasonable bond. Our team of criminal defense attorneys has provided legal representation for clients in almost every county within South Carolina.

Honest Advice on Possible Outcomes

Could you imagine your criminal defense lawyer painting a positive picture of your case, only to be charged with a felony resulting in years of prison time? At Lauren Taylor Law, we aren't in the business of sugar-coating your case or bending the truth. We understand the potential consequences of a conviction and can offer guidance on the best course of action for your specific case.

Our experienced attorneys are knowledgeable about the tendencies of judges in South Carolina and can advise you on whether to accept a plea deal or fight the charges in court. We prioritize your best interests and work to ensure the best possible outcome for your case. That way, you have a fair shot at freedom and living a normal life outside of the South Carolina court system.

Abbeville Attorney Spartanburg, SC
Legal Defense Spartanburg, SC

When Is It Time to Hire a Criminal Defense Lawyer Near Me Spartanburg, SC?

cd-head-bottom

Ask Us Anything

Criminal Charges Spartanburg, SC

One of the most common questions we hear from prospective clients is, "When should I hire a criminal defense attorney for my case Near Me Spartanburg, SC?" While no two situations or clients are ever truly the same, there are common criminal situations to consider. Here are some guidelines to help you determine when it's appropriate to hire a criminal defense attorney for your case:

  • If you have been accused of committing a crime
  • When you are involved directly with a crime
  • When you are considered to be a party to a crime, such as when you aid in or plan a crime
  • If you hurt someone unintentionally
  • If you have been charged with a felony or misdemeanor, such as petty theft or assault with a deadly weapon

If you have been associated with any convictions mentioned above, it is crucial to seek the assistance of a lawyer or law firm experienced in handling such cases. Losing a case could have severe consequences, and you need expert guidance to navigate through the legal process. At Lauren Taylor Law, our criminal defense attorneys are well-versed in handling such cases and can offer you a consultation to help you understand your rights.

Understanding the Arrest Process in South Carolina

If you have been accused of a crime, you and your family are probably curious about the process that lies ahead regarding your criminal case. Generally speaking, the process for criminal cases in South Carolina is as follows:

Investigation: Law enforcement will investigate and gather evidence before charging you with a crime.

number-one

Charges: After your arrest, you will have a trial to determine the charges being presented against you. It's recommended to find a lawyer as soon as possible to help defend your case.

number-two

Initial hearing: You will be brought before a magistrate judge to learn more about the charges being brought against you.

number-three

Discovery: Before the trial, the prosecutor and your attorney will gather evidence and information to prepare their cases. This includes finding witnesses to testify during the trial.

number-four

Plea bargaining: If the case against you is strong, the prosecutor may offer a plea deal to lessen the severity of the sentencing. If you plead guilty, there will be no trial, and the charges will be determined.

Legal Representation Spartanburg, SC
Court Defense Spartanburg, SC
number-five

Preliminary hearing: In some cases, there may be a hearing to present evidence in your favor before the trial, after you have chosen to plead not guilty.

number-six

Pre-trial motions: Before the trial, the prosecutor can make a motion to decide on a certain issue. These motions range from dismissing a charge to moving the trial venue.

number-seven

Trial: Both sides present their case during the trial and bring in evidence to convince the jury. Shortly after the trial, the verdict is announced.

By understanding the legal process for criminal cases in South Carolina, you can better prepare for what's ahead and work with your criminal defense attorney Near Me Spartanburg, SC, to defend your case.

Common Criminal Cases at Lauren Taylor Law

cd-head-bottom

Having served criminal defense clients in South Carolina for years, our team of experienced lawyers has worked with a litany of cases, from minor misdemeanors to serious felonies. We understand that no two issues are the same and that every client has unique needs and concerns regarding their case. We also understand that knowledge can go a long way, and as such, would like to summarize some standard cases our attorneys work with daily:

What Clients Say About Us

Taylor Law icon

DUIs: Driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs can result in a fine or jail time. A SC DUI lawyer can defend your rights during your case.

Misdemeanors

Misdemeanors: These crimes are less severe than felonies and are usually punishable with fines and jail time. Many of the crimes we handle at Lauren Taylor Law are misdemeanors at the state level.

Burglary

Burglary: When you enter a home and commit theft, you've committed a burglary. This crime is a felony and, as such, can result in up to 10 years of prison time.

Domestic Violence

Domestic Violence: This type of crime can range from abuse in the family home to a fight in public. Penalties for domestic abuse range in severity and can change if an injury is involved.

Drug Charges

Drug Charges: Drug charges are very common in South Carolina and can range from possession, intent to deliver, and trafficking.

Shoplifting

Shoplifting: This crime is a form of theft that may be classified as an infraction rather than a misdemeanor in certain cases.

Theft

Theft: Theft, or larceny, is defined as unlawfully taking possessions that belong to an entity or person. Theft is different from burglary and shoplifting, though prosecutors often stack those charges together.

Weapons Charges

Weapons Charges: Possessing, utilizing, or selling an unlicensed weapon are all examples of weapons charges, which can carry very serious consequences in South Carolina.

Juvenile Crimes

Juvenile Crimes: When it comes to criminal charges involving minors, the term "juvenile crime" refers to offenses committed by individuals under the age of 18. However, depending on the seriousness of the crime, some young people may face trial as adults.

Violent Crimes

Violent Crimes: When an individual is subjected to or threatened with violence, it is considered a violent crime.

Abbeville Law Firm Spartanburg, SC

Uncompromising Advocacy without Judgement

cd-head-bottom

Lauren Taylor Law is the go-to choice for clients who value honesty, hard work, and transparent communication. Our mission is not to judge individuals who have been accused of crimes. Rather, we aim to secure the best possible defense for our clients while upholding their rights and freedom. If you or someone you care about is facing criminal charges in South Carolina, don't leave your fate to chance. Take the necessary precautions to protect yourself before it's too late - contact a Lauren Taylor Law criminal defense attorney Near Me Spartanburg, SC today.

phone-number843-790-9009

Make an Apportment

Latest News Near Me Spartanburg, SC

Spartanburg Sc motel shooting triggers AMBER Alert as deputies confirm one injured and no custody

SPARTANBURG COUNTY, S. C. (Friday, ET) — A shooting at a Spartanburg County motel has escalated from an on-scene response into a broader search effort after authorities issued an AMBER Alert tied to the incident. deputies were sent to the Rodeway Inn on New Cut Road around 11: 36 a. m., where one person was injured. As of the latest official update, no one is in custody, underscoring that the situation remains active as investigators work to develop leads in spartanburg sc.What officials have c...

SPARTANBURG COUNTY, S. C. (Friday, ET) — A shooting at a Spartanburg County motel has escalated from an on-scene response into a broader search effort after authorities issued an AMBER Alert tied to the incident. deputies were sent to the Rodeway Inn on New Cut Road around 11: 36 a. m., where one person was injured. As of the latest official update, no one is in custody, underscoring that the situation remains active as investigators work to develop leads in spartanburg sc.

What officials have confirmed so far in Spartanburg Sc

The Spartanburg County Sheriff’s Office said it is responding to a shooting at a motel on Friday. Deputies said one person was hurt at the Rodeway Inn on New Cut Road around 11: 36 a. m. (ET). Authorities also stated that no one was in custody at the time of the update.

Shortly before 3 p. m. (ET), authorities issued an AMBER Alert connected to the incident. The alert included a vehicle description: they are looking for a white 2010 Mitsubishi Outlander with South Carolina tag 669BMX.

AMBER Alert issuance adds urgency to the investigation

The decision to issue an AMBER Alert several hours after the initial call signals that investigators are treating the incident as more than an isolated shooting scene. While officials have not released additional details in the publicly available update, the alert indicates law enforcement is seeking rapid public awareness around a specific vehicle believed to be relevant.

In practical terms, an AMBER Alert changes the operating tempo of a case: it extends attention beyond the motel property, focuses the public on an actionable identifier, and can widen the search area as tips and sightings are evaluated. At this stage, officials have not announced an arrest, and the lack of a person in custody keeps the outcome uncertain in spartanburg sc.

What remains unknown and what to watch next

Authorities have not publicly provided the condition of the injured person beyond confirming that one individual was hurt. Officials also have not disclosed information on a suspect, a motive, or the circumstances that led to the shooting at the Rodeway Inn. The AMBER Alert announcement did not include additional narrative details in the available statement.

Key developments that would clarify the scope of the event include any official confirmation of who is connected to the white 2010 Mitsubishi Outlander with tag 669BMX, whether investigators have a description of a person of interest, and whether additional safety guidance is issued. For now, the confirmed facts remain limited to the response time, the location, the injury, the absence of custody, and the AMBER Alert vehicle information connected to the case in spartanburg sc.

Obituary For Jaylin Nicole Simpson

Jaylin Nicole Simpson was born February 11, 2018 to Jacosha Simpson and Jamarcus Wade. In her 8 years of life, she found many joys in her family, her friends and her faith. Jaylin loved attending church with her grandmother at Macedonia Missionary Baptist Church, her great-grandmother at Greater New Hope, and even would join her grandfather at Greater Target AME Church in Hollyhill, SC.Aside from her faith, Jaylin enjoyed all things creative, girly and cats. She drew pictures and made dolls out of everything she could find. Her love f...

Jaylin Nicole Simpson was born February 11, 2018 to Jacosha Simpson and Jamarcus Wade. In her 8 years of life, she found many joys in her family, her friends and her faith. Jaylin loved attending church with her grandmother at Macedonia Missionary Baptist Church, her great-grandmother at Greater New Hope, and even would join her grandfather at Greater Target AME Church in Hollyhill, SC.

Aside from her faith, Jaylin enjoyed all things creative, girly and cats. She drew pictures and made dolls out of everything she could find. Her love for music was just as strong. She loved to record videos of her and her friends doing day to day things. She spent the most time with her cousins. She was a very bright student as well and although she didn't like school, she excelled. She loved to travel and see new places, on her list of must sees was New York and Paris.

Jaylin knew how to be the boss and even had a couple of babies of her own: Hailey, Bailey, Kaylie, Aylie and Lolie.

In addition to her parents, left to cherish fond and loving memories are: maternal grandparents, Rita Simpson and James (Renee) McKissick; paternal grandparents, Jamie Fuller and Marcus Wade; great-grandparents, Deloris and Henry James and Lettie Fuller; aunts, Markesha Fuller, Tynesha (Jaylin) Hynes and Klarke McKissick; brothers, Kace and Koree McCreary; cousins, Angela Wallace and Cameron Fuller; godmothers, Briana McCreary and Mariah Chapel; and a host of cousins and extended family members she also loved dearly.

She was preceded in death by: her aunt, Victoria Fuller and her uncle, Jeremiah Gilliam.

Jaylin lived a wonderful 8 years and was loved by everyone she held dear, and she loved us all as well. Please keep Baby Jaylin ,"Sugar Sugar", our sweet girl in your thoughts and prayers.

Funeral Services will be held on Sunday, March 22, 2026 at 2:00 p.m. at Macedonia Missionary Baptist Church, Spartanburg, SC. Burial will be in the Heritage Memorial Gardens, Roebuck, SC.

Public Viewing will be held on Saturday, March 20, 2026 from 5:00 p.m. - 8:00 p.m. at The John Stinson Woodward Memorial Chapel.

In Honor of Jaylin's love for tea parties, the family kindly requests tea party attire for her homegoing celebration.

South Carolina weather: Damaging winds, isolated tornadoes and hail possible

Severe storms are possible Sunday and Monday across the Upstate of South Carolina, western North Carolina, and northeast Georgia, with threats including damaging straight-line winds, isolated tornadoes, large hail, and heavy rain.Live radar:Severe threat Monday:MONDAY: Impact Day due to severe storm potentialKeep up with what's happening around our area by downloading the WYFF News 4 app on the App Store or Google Play....

Severe storms are possible Sunday and Monday across the Upstate of South Carolina, western North Carolina, and northeast Georgia, with threats including damaging straight-line winds, isolated tornadoes, large hail, and heavy rain.

Live radar:

Severe threat Monday:

MONDAY: Impact Day due to severe storm potential

Keep up with what's happening around our area by downloading the WYFF News 4 app on the App Store or Google Play.

*** A burst of snow is likely in WNC by the afternoon as the front departs. Light accumulation, mainly on elevated surfaces, is possible. ***

The wind will pick up behind Monday's powerful cold front. A Wind Advisory is in place for the highlighted areas above 3500 feet in western North Carolina. Wind gusts of 50-60 mph are expected.

TUESDAY: Impact Day due to frigid temperatures & wind chills

WEDNESDAY: Impact Day due to another cold morning. Lows in the teens & 20s.

The WYFF News 4 weather team has been independently certified for having the most accurate forecast in the Greenville-Spartanburg-Asheville-Anderson market for the second year in a row.

"Our goal every day, in every forecast is accuracy," said WYFF 4 President and General Manager Blake Bridges. "Our expert weather team is dedicated to giving viewers a forecast they can trust to be right. We are also the only station in the market with our own 24/7 live radar, Live Super Doppler 4. It’s clear that WYFF News 4 is the weather leader in this market."

The certification comes from WeatheRate, an independent research firm that tracks forecasts from every station in multiple markets across the country.

"Everyone knows that forecasting the weather around here is difficult with the Upstate and mountains," said WeatheRate President Bruce Fixman. "The station that gets the forecast right more than anyone else is Chief Meteorologist Chris Justus and the WYFF News 4 weather team."

South Carolina: Damaging winds, isolated tornadoes, hail and heavy rain possible

GREENVILLE, S.C. —Severe storms are possible on Monday in the Upstate of South Carolina, western North Carolina and northeast Georgia.Storms may produce damaging, straight-line winds, isolated tornadoes, large hail and heavy rain.Live radar:Severe threat Monday:MONDAY: Impact Day due to severe storm potentialDownload the free WYFF News 4 App to receive weather alerts. Be sure your notifications are turned ON.*** A burst of ...

GREENVILLE, S.C. —

Severe storms are possible on Monday in the Upstate of South Carolina, western North Carolina and northeast Georgia.

Storms may produce damaging, straight-line winds, isolated tornadoes, large hail and heavy rain.

Live radar:

Severe threat Monday:

MONDAY: Impact Day due to severe storm potential

Download the free WYFF News 4 App to receive weather alerts. Be sure your notifications are turned ON.

*** A burst of snow is likely in WNC by the afternoon as the front departs. Light accumulation, mainly on elevated surfaces, is possible. ***

The wind will pick up behind Monday's powerful cold front. A Wind Advisory is in place for the highlighted areas above 3500 feet in western North Carolina. Wind gusts of 50-60 mph are expected.

TUESDAY: Impact Day due to frigid temperatures & wind chills

WEDNESDAY: Impact Day due to another cold morning. Lows in the teens & 20s.

The WYFF News 4 weather team has been independently certified for having the most accurate forecast in the Greenville-Spartanburg-Asheville-Anderson market for the second year in a row.

"Our goal every day, in every forecast is accuracy," said WYFF 4 President and General Manager Blake Bridges. "Our expert weather team is dedicated to giving viewers a forecast they can trust to be right. We are also the only station in the market with our own 24/7 live radar, Live Super Doppler 4. It’s clear that WYFF News 4 is the weather leader in this market."

The certification comes from WeatheRate, an independent research firm that tracks forecasts from every station in multiple markets across the country.

"Everyone knows that forecasting the weather around here is difficult with the Upstate and mountains," said WeatheRate President Bruce Fixman. "The station that gets the forecast right more than anyone else is Chief Meteorologist Chris Justus and the WYFF News 4 weather team."

BMW discriminated against employee for being American, jury says with $5M verdict

SPARTANBURG — A jury delivered a $5.1 million verdict against BMW last month after determining the Spartanburg plant discriminated against an American employee on the basis of her nationality, in violation of federal Title VII protections.Kelly Dawsey of Greenville left her job in 2021 after learning of a reorganization that replaced her German boss with an American one, according to court records.BMW had a long-standing policy mandating alternate German and domestic positions among senior managers, court records said, wh...

SPARTANBURG — A jury delivered a $5.1 million verdict against BMW last month after determining the Spartanburg plant discriminated against an American employee on the basis of her nationality, in violation of federal Title VII protections.

Kelly Dawsey of Greenville left her job in 2021 after learning of a reorganization that replaced her German boss with an American one, according to court records.

BMW had a long-standing policy mandating alternate German and domestic positions among senior managers, court records said, where no two consecutive managers in the chain of command could be American.

For Dawsey, getting an American boss meant the company would have to replace her with a German. Indeed, the company had made plans to replace Dawsey with a German and transfer her to a new role, court records said.

She left before being offered any alternative position and filed the suit in October 2022. It went to trial this year, where a jury agreed that BMW discriminated against her because she was American.

The jury awarded her $100,000 in compensatory damages and $5 million in punitive damages. But since the damages in employment discrimination cases are capped at $300,000, that’s likely all she will receive, plus possible economic damages in the form of lost or future wages.

“We were surprised and disappointed by the outcome,” BMW spokesman Steve Wilson said in an email. “While we disagree, we respect the jury’s decision. We are currently evaluating potential post-trial and appellate options.”

Dawsey’s attorney, Brian Murphy, did not respond to requests for comment.

But Jeremy Summerlin, a Greenville employment attorney who followed the case, said the verdict was a rare occurrence for several reasons.

Nationality-based discrimination claims are less common than sex-based, race-based, age-based or disability-based claims, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission statistics. When they do occur, he said, they usually don’t come from Americans. And generally, employment cases are settled before they get to a jury.

“You don’t see a lot of cases like this go to trial,” said Summerlin, who wrote about the case in his own blog. “Something like 97 percent of cases are going to be settled or dismissed at summary judgment before trial.”

Dawsey began working at BMW in 1995 and had worked her way up to department manager for human resources planning and steering, which reports directly to the vice president of human resources.

Before a planned reorganization, the vice president was a German national. When the German left, an American was brought in to fill the role.

Dawsey learned that a reorganization was in the works in the spring of 2021. In early September, before she learned she would be replaced by a German national, she reached out to a recruiter to look for other jobs.

BMW argued in a motion for summary judgment that Dawsey didn’t have a case, in part because she was looking to leave her position before she learned who was replacing her, and that her job transfer would be a lateral move.

In a motion opposing BMW’s request for summary judgment, Dawsey said that she only began looking for other opportunities after communication about the changes became “chaotic” and she wanted “to see if there were alternatives if she was left out.”

Dawsey pointed out that she only accepted employment elsewhere after BMW told her she would be moved to a job that she considered a demotion.

Major questions left up to the jury included whether BMW’s policy of requiring a German in the chain of command violated Title VII and whether moving Dawsey to another role would have been a demotion that could be considered an adverse employment action.

“BMW’s position is that she was being moved laterally, but the testimony, the argument was that position was a lower classification and the plaintiff had worked there for a long, long time,” Summerlin said. “And she was aware that that job was basically a black hole and nobody got promoted out of that position. She knew ‘If they stick me there, that’s basically the end.’ ”

A judge ruled against BMW on its motion for summary judgment, and the case moved forward, eventually ending in a trial.

On Feb. 25, a jury in the Greenville federal courthouse sided with Dawsey.

A hearing on economic damages is scheduled March 13.

Disclaimer:

This website publishes news articles that contain copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. The non-commercial use of these news articles for the purposes of local news reporting constitutes "Fair Use" of the copyrighted materials as provided for in Section 107 of the US Copyright Law.
Criminal Justice Spartanburg, SC

Service Areas