Most people who buy a home and the land it sits on expect that it will be theirs for as long as they choose to reside there. They may choose to pass that home and land along to children or other family members once they pass. It's a very common scenario, but for some residents of Charleston County, it may not be possible due to a highway expansion. Once the expansion starts, these residents could actually lose their land. And while you wouldn't think such an action would be legal in America, truth is often stranger than fiction.
The newly proposed expansion on Highway 41 will expand the highway to two lanes, increasing it to a total of four lanes on most of the roadway and from two to three lanes near the Phillips Community. The project would also start construction of Laurel Hill Parkway - a two-lane road that intersects through the outskirts of Laurel Hill County Park. For the Phillips Community, which sits adjacent to the highway, it could mean the loss of residents' homes and land that have been in their families for generations.
So, what can people like those in the Phillips Community do? They don't want to lose their homes or bear the burden of significantly more traffic around them. On their own, the options can be dour. But with the help of eminent domain attorneys in Folly Beach, SC, these families can receive the just compensation they deserve.
Remember that when you purchase or are given a plot of land, your property rights aren't as absolute as you may think. According to the United States Constitution, the government has the authority to take your property under specific circumstances. Essentially, your property rights are not absolute.
What's interesting is that the government's ability to take your property is actually stated in the Constitution. Even though the Constitution states that "private property shall not be taken for public use without just compensation," in essence, this means the government can take your property if the intended use is valid and they compensate you fairly. The Supreme Court upheld this view in 1876, interpreting that the government had this power based on the Constitution. Eminent domain was frequently used during the construction of the nation's railroad system, often without sufficient limitations on the government.
Unfortunately, many South Carolina residents end up being on the wrong end of the cost-benefit analysis when it comes to fair compensation. That's why, if the government is trying to take your land, it's so important to get in touch with eminent domain attorneys in Folly Beach, SC, as soon as possible. That way, you have someone by your side for any legal proceedings or disputes. At Lauren Taylor Law, we have a proven track record of achieving positive outcomes for our clients in cases where the government has failed to fulfill its legal responsibilities.
There are typically two different ways that the government may take your property. Those include:
In both scenarios, you could be forced into litigation in order to protect your rights, even though you had no plans on doing so.
When the government wants to acquire your land, they will typically begin by making a formal offer to buy your property. At this point, you may have the opportunity to negotiate with them. If you decide that selling your property is the best option, it's important to work towards reaching an agreement with the government on the sale price. This isn't always a straightforward process because the government may not be willing to offer you a fair amount.
To determine the price of your property, the government will have their appraiser assess the value of the property. This appraiser functions much like an adjuster for an insurance company, many of whom offer lowball pricing. You should know that you have the right to hire your own appraiser to determine an independent valuation. This is often the best course of action if you're considering selling to the government.
If you choose not to sell to the government, they may proceed by filing a lawsuit to initiate the condemnation process. At this point, you can challenge the taking itself by working with eminent domain attorneys in Folly Beach, SC. You can also ask the court to determine the fair market value of the property if the government's valuation is lower than what you believe is fair.
Given the history of these cases, you can never trust the government to act fairly. Why? Because local officials often have interests in such matters, and your rights are getting in their way. Sometimes, the only viable route you have is to lawyer up and fight the case in court.
When the government wants to acquire your land, they will typically begin by making a formal offer to buy your property. At this point, you may have the opportunity to negotiate with them. If you decide that selling your property is the best option, it's important to work towards reaching an agreement with the government on the sale price. This isn't always a straightforward process because the government may not be willing to offer you a fair amount.
To determine the price of your property, the government will have their appraiser assess the value of the property. This appraiser functions much like an adjuster for an insurance company, many of whom offer lowball pricing. You should know that you have the right to hire your own appraiser to determine an independent valuation. This is often the best course of action if you're considering selling to the government.
If you choose not to sell to the government, they may proceed by filing a lawsuit to initiate the condemnation process. At this point, you can challenge the taking itself by working with eminent domain attorneys in Folly Beach, SC. You can also ask the court to determine the fair market value of the property if the government's valuation is lower than what you believe is fair.
While the government can use its power to take your land, there are limits on its ability to do so. Namely:
As such, there are two reasons why you can sue the government as part of an eminent domain case:
Given the history of these cases, you can never trust the government to act fairly. Why? Because local officials often have interests in such matters, and your rights are getting in their way. Sometimes, the only viable route you have is to lawyer up and fight the case in court.
Landowners commonly contest whether the taking is genuinely for public use. There are constraints on the government's actions and the reasons for which they can seize your land. The interpretation of these terms by the courts often favors the government. "Public use" does not simply mean that your property would be open to the general public. Instead, the term is more akin to "for the benefit of the public."
Historically, the government expropriated private lands for projects such as bridges and highways. Numerous legal battles arose during the period when the nation was constructing its railroad system. In these instances, the courts typically interpreted "public use" more broadly.
Some of the most common reasons why government landtaking is upheld include the building of structures like:
These are the more "traditional" uses of eminent domain, where the public use would be less in question. However, the law also permits certain utilities to wield the power of eminent domain. For instance, in a recent case in South Carolina, Dominion Energy was granted the authority to acquire homes in order to construct an energy pipeline.
Regrettably, governments have historically tended to misuse this authority, and some courts have even condoned such actions. As an example, courts in Toledo, Ohio, allowed 83 homes to be taken from residents in order to construct a manufacturing plant for Chrysler, which said the plant would create jobs for the public.
If the government is trying to take your land, you should never give up on your property. By working with eminent domain attorneys in Folly Beach, SC, you may be able to stop them by challenging the taking itself. You can also challenge the purpose of the taking and argue that the reason for "public use" is really for private use.
Many people worry about the government taking over their entire piece of land. However, in some cases, the government may not need all your property and might not want to compensate you for it. They may only require a portion of your land.
In such instances, the government not only has to pay you for the part of the land they are taking, but they also have to compensate for the decreased value of the remaining land that you still own. Additionally, the government may seek to obtain an easement on your land through eminent domain. This easement could be for utilities or access to another area. Once again, the government must compensate you for the land taken and for the reduction in value of the rest of your property.
In essence, fair market value represents the amount a willing buyer would offer to a seller for their property. While this concept seems straightforward, applying fair market value in reality can be quite challenging. In many instances, negotiating with the government may be necessary to receive proper compensation for your land. Just like any negotiator, the government typically begins with a low offer and anticipates a counteroffer from you to reach a mutual agreement. Rarely does the government present its best offer right from the start.
Several valuations may be considered to determine your property's fair market value:
The amount of income your property could have produced
Comparison of sales to other similar properties in the area that were recently sold (there could be disagreements pertaining to what is comparable)
The amount of money it would cost to replace your property (and the structures built on it) minus depreciation
In reality, during a trial, both you and the government would have valuation experts testify. First, you'd have to choose the relevant valuation, which the government might dispute. Then, you'd need to apply the appropriate valuation method. There might be a significant difference between your numbers and the government's.
However, even if you couldn't prevent the seizure of the property, many have successfully challenged the government's valuation of their property. Property owners have compelled the government to pay more, and our team of eminent domain attorneys in Folly Beach, SC, has represented many of them in the legal process over the years.
For Any Help, Questions or Suggestions, Contact Us
Typically, you'll receive notice regarding the potential acquisition of your property through a letter. But if you're like the residents of the Phillips Community, you might have already heard murmurs that something might happen to your land. If you suspect or find out that the government plans to take your land through eminent domain, you need the help of seasoned eminent domain attorneys in Folly Beach, SC, right away.
The truth is that the government can be just as challenging to deal with as an insurance company. Despite your constitutional rights, they might try to conceal information or offer far less compensation than your property is worth.
In an eminent domain lawsuit, you're essentially challenging the government. While some courts might show some level of deference to the government, they are not given free rein to do as they please. It's within your rights to stand up and contest the government's actions if they violate your rights. But to fight back effectively, your best bet is to work with an eminent domain lawyer from Lauren Taylor Law.
Your attorney will assess the best legal approach for your case, which could involve suing the government or vigorously defending against their lawsuit. You could also negotiate compensation, either before or after the case goes to court.
If you receive notice that your property is being targeted for eminent domain action, also known as condemnation, it's important to seek advice from an eminent domain attorney. Many people won't reach out to a lawyer when dealing with this kind of legal issue because they:
Unfortunately, these assumptions are rarely, if ever, true. In fact, you may actually be more vulnerable and at risk than you originally thought. This misunderstanding illustrates exactly why you should enlist the services of a reputable eminent domain attorney. With the assistance of a legal expert who is well-versed in South Carolina eminent domain law, property owners can safeguard their rights and secure maximum compensation.
Here are the top three ways an eminent domain lawyer can help:
It's important to keep in mind that the initial offer from the government for your property is often the lowest amount they think they can get away with. This rarely represents the full and fair compensation you deserve. An attorney has the expertise and resources to ensure that you receive proper compensation for the value of your property, including relocation expenses and more.
In some instances, an eminent domain attorney may be able to secure a higher amount than what the government is proposing. The eminent domain lawyers at Lauren Taylor Law are dedicated to safeguarding your rights and protecting your property
Government agencies are not permitted to simply take any property they desire. According to the 5th Amendment, they must prove that the condemnation is genuinely for public use and meets other specific criteria. You have the right to demand that the state fulfill these criteria before seizing your property. Plus, if only a portion of your property is necessary to complete the project, you have the right to safeguard the ownership of the remaining part of your property.
Eminent domain cases and their related laws can be quite intricate and overwhelming for the average property owner. You shouldn't be expected to grasp all the technical terms, and you certainly shouldn't be penalized for not fully understanding the process. That's why having an experienced eminent domain lawyer by your side is valuable on many levels. A skilled eminent domain attorney will assist you through each stage in plain language that you can grasp. With an eminent domain attorney advocating for you throughout your case to safeguard your rights, you stand a better chance of receiving the compensation you rightfully deserve.
If the government takes your property or prevents you from using it, you have the right to file a lawsuit. The law provides you with the opportunity to stand on equal ground with our government, allowing your lawyer to advocate for your rights in court.
At Lauren Taylor Law, our eminent domain lawyers step in so you don't get pushed around. Our goal is to fight the government on your behalf, so you get the compensation you deserve. Contact our office today to learn more about eminent domain in South Carolina and how our firm can help.
FOLLY BEACH — This island community elected a new face to city council on Feb. 17 — one that looks familiar.Folly Beach chose D.J. Rich to serve on city council, unofficial election night results show. Rich has previously served on council for a combined 14 years.Rich secured 58 percent of votes cast on Feb. 17. John McFarland trailed behind, earning 41.6 percent of votes cast, unofficial results show.Rich’s victory marked the end of a long-lasting election cycle for Folly Beach, where Charleston County...
FOLLY BEACH — This island community elected a new face to city council on Feb. 17 — one that looks familiar.
Folly Beach chose D.J. Rich to serve on city council, unofficial election night results show. Rich has previously served on council for a combined 14 years.
Rich secured 58 percent of votes cast on Feb. 17. John McFarland trailed behind, earning 41.6 percent of votes cast, unofficial results show.
Rich’s victory marked the end of a long-lasting election cycle for Folly Beach, where Charleston County’s Board of Voter Registrations and Elections has hosted three elections on the island since last November.
Chris Bizzell was elected as mayor in a runoff election in November which left a vacant spot on council, triggering a special election to fill the seat.
In the days leading up to the election, Rich encouraged Folly Beach voters to turn out to the polls on Tuesday. In a message shared to Facebook on Feb. 16, he wrote that he ran for city council once more to “help our new administration move Folly forward responsibly.”
“I’m not a one trick pony,” Rich wrote. “I have full experience after 14 years on council and 4 as mayor pro-tem helping navigate us through a full range of issues.”
Rich ran unsuccessfully for mayor of Folly Beach last fall. He earned the third-most votes on Nov. 4, trailing behind candidates Elton Culpepper and Bizzell, failing to make the runoff. Bizzell was sworn in as mayor on Nov. 21, 2025.
But this time, Rich found success.
McFarland, a long-time property owner on the island, moved to Folly Beach full-time in 2025. Shortly after, he filed to run for city council, but fell short of winning a seat. The founder of Save Folly’s Future could often be found stumping outside the community’s sole post office on East Indian Avenue.
Charleston may get most of the attention when it comes to South Carolina’s many cities, but the history, culture, and (of course) Southern charm that make it so special can also be found in smaller and less expensive places in the region. If you’ve ever watched “Forrest Gump” or read anything by the late author Pat Conroy, you may be familiar with Beaufort, a harbor town on Port Royal Island. While its narrow streets, oak trees, and historic district that pre-dates the Civil War are similar to those in Charleston, Bea...
Charleston may get most of the attention when it comes to South Carolina’s many cities, but the history, culture, and (of course) Southern charm that make it so special can also be found in smaller and less expensive places in the region. If you’ve ever watched “Forrest Gump” or read anything by the late author Pat Conroy, you may be familiar with Beaufort, a harbor town on Port Royal Island. While its narrow streets, oak trees, and historic district that pre-dates the Civil War are similar to those in Charleston, Beaufort is remarkable and magical in its own right. Plus, it doesn’t draw the same crowds that tend to flock to notable Holy City hangouts like King Street, Folly Beach, and the Battery.
Before you read any further, though, you need to know how to properly pronounce the name. Not to be confused with Beaufort, North Carolina (said like “bow-fert”), the coastal town has a pronunciation more akin to “bew-fert.” Mistaking the two will immediately identify you as a tourist—and it won’t sit too well with the locals. Once you have that squared away, you can start planning your trip to Beaufort, the second-oldest city in South Carolina.
In 1969, Beaufort became one of the few U.S. cities with an entire downtown designated as a historic district by the National Trust for Historic Preservation, so exploring the neighborhoods filled with Victorian, Greek Revival, Neoclassical, and Federal-style homes is at the top of most travelers’ lists. At Henry C. Chambers Waterfront Park, you’ll spot Woods Memorial Bridge, recognizable from the aforementioned Tom Hanks blockbuster. Stretching your legs is also encouraged along the Spanish Moss Trail, a 10.2-mile greenway that weaves by Beaufort’s marshes and through trees draped in Spanish moss. Given its waterfront location, Beaufort should also be experienced by boat; book a Dolphin & History Boat Cruise with Coastal Expeditions or an ecology tour with Beaufort Kayak Tours. Paddleboarding is another option, with rental equipment available through Higher Ground Outfitters.
Beaufort’s ties to the literary world are strong; visiting the Pat Conroy Literary Center (this was Conroy’s adopted hometown) or one of the three independent bookstores in town—NeverMore Books, McIntosh Book Shoppe, or Beaufort Books—is a must for book lovers. For those interested in local art, there's the Rhett Gallery, Thibault Gallery, or Atelier Off Bay.
Many of the best things to do in Beaufort are found outside downtown. About 17 miles east is Hunting Island State Park, with its pristine beaches, marshes, maritime forest, and saltwater lagoon. It's also home to the Hunting Island Lighthouse, which was destroyed during the Civil War and rebuilt in 1875. St. Helena Island (a 15-minute drive away) is home to the Penn Center—one of the United States’ first schools for formerly enslaved individuals—as well as the family-owned Dempsey Farms, where you can pick in-season fruits and vegetables. Local produce can also be acquired on Saturdays at the nearby Port Royal Farmers Market.
Enhance your visit to Beaufort with a stay in one of the town’s upscale inns. Slow Southern mornings paired with a home-cooked breakfast can be enjoyed on the expansive wooden porch at The Rhett House Inn. Guests can also book the more modern Rhett House Inn Cottages, which sit across the street from the main building. Once a Union Army hospital, Anchorage 1770 overlooks the Beaufort River and offers a fine dining experience at The Ribaut Social Club. The Beaufort Inn first opened its doors in 1897, and the property’s modern-day chapter features several fully renovated buildings within the town’s historic district.
As with most Southern cities and towns, food is a major part of the local culture. If you’re a traveler who plans their vacations around meals, you’ll want to start your day at Blackstone’s Cafe or Herban Market and Cafe. For a quick lunch while exploring Beaufort, stop by Lowcountry Produce Market & Cafe to get a fried chicken sandwich or po’boy. Chapman’s Grocer also has grab-and-go treats, wine, and craft beer. Old Bull Tavern is a lively gastropub open only for dinner, Saltus River Grill is great for indulging in seafood, and those craving Italian should dine at Griffin Market. On St. Helena Island, The Gullah Grub Restaurant is one of the area’s most famous eateries (it appeared on Anthony Bourdain: No Reservations); order the shrimp gumbo.
When considering the best time to visit South Carolina, there are a few things to keep in mind. Summers here are hot and humid—there’s no getting around that. To explore Beaufort in the most comfortable climate, your best bet is to go in either early spring or late fall. April and October are ideal—you'll find plenty to do (winter is far from bustling) while simultaneously avoiding the sweltering weather that's synonymous with the South.
Hilton Head Island Airport (HHH) and Savannah/Hilton Head International Airport (SAV) are both about an hour's drive away. You’ll need to rent a car to fully experience Beaufort and its surrounding area. Charleston International Airport (CHS) is also an option, although it’ll take about 90 minutes to drive to Beaufort.
South Carolina delivers some of the South’s best trips, from barrier island beaches and salt marshes to local markets in historic districts. Edisto Island, a quiet and lightly developed sea island, is worth the trip for the 1.7-mile Spanish Mount Trail, which leads to a 4,000-year-old shell midden. Beaufort, with its antebellum character and live oak-lined streets, stands out for Cypress Wetlands, where visitors can spot alligators and river otters. And Newberry is especially memorable for the Wells Japanese Garden, with its moon bridg...
South Carolina delivers some of the South’s best trips, from barrier island beaches and salt marshes to local markets in historic districts. Edisto Island, a quiet and lightly developed sea island, is worth the trip for the 1.7-mile Spanish Mount Trail, which leads to a 4,000-year-old shell midden. Beaufort, with its antebellum character and live oak-lined streets, stands out for Cypress Wetlands, where visitors can spot alligators and river otters. And Newberry is especially memorable for the Wells Japanese Garden, with its moon bridge and Torii gate, as well as the historic Newberry Opera House downtown. There is plenty of history and natural beauty waiting to be discovered across the state, and the eight towns below show just how rewarding a long weekend in South Carolina can be.
Edisto Island is quiet and largely uninhabited, making it the perfect destination for those wanting to disconnect and unwind. The island's highlight is Edisto Beach State Park, featuring a maritime forest with palmetto trees and rich salt marshes. One of the park's most popular trails, the Spanish Mount Trail, is a 1.7-mile path leading to a 4,000-year-old shell midden that has gradually eroded over time. For those who want to stay immersed in the island’s natural beauty, Edisto Beach State Park also offers rustic cabins tucked among the palmettos and live oaks. The cozy, no-frills cabins sit just steps from the shoreline, allowing visitors to wake up to ocean breezes, spend the day exploring the park’s trails and beaches, and end the evening listening to the sound of waves under a sky full of stars.
Just a short 25-minute drive from Charleston, Folly Beach is a lovely escape with a population of just over 2,000. Stroll along the historic Folly Pier, built in the 1930s, and take in the breathtaking ocean views. Folly Beach County Park is perfect for those looking to swim, sunbathe, or walk along the shore, with lifeguards present during the summer months.
For a taste of fresh, home-cooked seafood, visit Coconut Joe's, conveniently located just a block from the beach. The town also offers a variety of charming inns and hotels, including the Regatta Inn, which features a waterfront view, a sunset terrace, and complimentary golf cart shuttles for added convenience.
Bluffton offers a waterside escape of its own, centered around the scenic May River rather than the Atlantic. Here, visitors can enjoy numerous recreational activities along the river, including dolphin tours, fishing charters, kayaking, and paddleboarding. The town also highlights local artisans and vendors through markets like the Lowcountry Made Artisan Market, an open-air venue showcasing handmade goods, and the Bluffton Farmer’s Market, where you can find fresh produce, spices, barbecue, and honey. If you're searching for a true Southern-style place to stay, consider May River Manor, which boasts 5.5 acres of lush greenery, a pool, and an outdoor patio for a relaxing getaway.
The town of Beaufort sits on Port Royal Island, surrounded by marshy estuaries and shaded by streets lined with live oak trees. The area is home to over 100 bird species, and the nearby Cypress Wetlands, just a ten-minute drive away, are an excellent spot for exploring the wetland ecosystem. Here, you can see diverse wildlife, including minks, river otters, marsh rabbits, and alligators. Beaufort's downtown area is filled with charming local shops, with highlights such as Beaufort River Glass, Monkey’s Uncle toy shop, and the Oyster Cay Collection antiques store. For a picturesque and historic stay, Anchorage 1770 is a heritage boutique inn on the waterfront.
Heading over to the western side of South Carolina, Aiken is renowned for its rich equestrian heritage, while also embodying the best of Southern charm and hospitality. Visitors can tour and meet the horses at Aiken Equine Rescue, the southeastern US’s largest equine rescue center. Those interested in racing can visit the Aiken Thoroughbred Racing Hall of Fame and Museum, which has a large collection of photographs and trophies from some of the country’s best equestrian riders.
The nature around Aiken is priceless as well. The Aiken Arboretum Trail in town, for example, features one of the country’s most diverse tree collections within a municipal landscape. Regarding a unique lodging option in town, The Carriage House Inn, dating back to 1872, is located in Aiken’s historic downtown district and provides a delicious complimentary breakfast and chocolate chip cookies to its guests.
Visitors cannot go wrong with a weekend trip away in Newberry. Its downtown historic district is a particular highlight, with landmarks like the Newberry Opera House and the Newberry Museum offering important insights into the town’s history. The Wells Japanese Garden is also on the National Registry of Historic Places, featuring a temple, moon bridge, Torri gate, and tea room.
Wine lovers will find plenty to enjoy in Newberry, with Enoree River Vineyards & Winery offering the perfect spot to spend an afternoon, surrounded by scenic views of the vineyard. For a quaint stay, the historic, family-run Newberry Manor, located just a block away from the Wells Japanese Garden, is a great option.
Sullivan’s Island is a relaxed, two-and-a-half-mile-long island home to a little over 2,000 residents, making for a quiet escape. After a leisurely morning stroll along its 2.5-mile shoreline, visitors can enjoy lunch at one of the town's coastal cuisine spots, like Sullivan’s Fish Camp. The town also has an involved artist presence, with visitors able to appreciate local art at galleries such as Sandpiper Gallery and Adele’s Pottery.
One of the island’s iconic landmarks is Fort Moultrie, the site of a pivotal nine-hour battle with the British during the Revolutionary War in 1776. The Palms Oceanfront Hotel is one of the nearest and most recommended lodging options, including spectacular views of the ocean, a newly renovated pool deck, and stylish, modern rooms.
If you're interested in South Carolina's history and culture, Pendleton is a must. The town boasts more than 50 historic buildings from the 18th and 19th centuries, numerous art galleries featuring works from local artists, and a vibrant bluegrass music scene. Notable historic sites include Timms Mill, a gristmill originally built along the Six and Twenty Creek in 1784 and relocated in 1898, as well as St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, established in 1822 and still featuring a Jardine pipe organ that has been playing for over 170 years.
To dive into the bluegrass scene, head to Breazeale’s Grocery Bluegrass on the weekends, where you can enjoy jam sessions and occasionally catch performances by nationally recognized artists. For lodging, Liberty Hall Bed & Breakfast, a beautifully restored home built in 1849, offers a charming accommodation option.
Whether you are a native-born South Carolinian or hail from another state, each of these towns offers unique and diverse attractions that will appeal to every member of the family. With everything from fresh seafood to art galleries and bird tours, these towns offer a wide variety of experiences that defy simple categorization. So get out your calendar, mark your dates, and start planning your next adventure in one of these amazing towns.
FOLLY BEACH, S.C. (WCIV) — A South Carolina appeals court has upheld Folly Beach’s limit on short-term rental licenses, allowing the city to keep its cap of 800 vacation rental permits.City leaders say the cap was approved by voters in 2023 with the goal of maintaining a balance between tourism and full-time residents on the island.The decision comes after some property owners challenged the policy in court, arguing the cap prevented them from renting their homes short-term. However, the court sided with the city, r...
FOLLY BEACH, S.C. (WCIV) — A South Carolina appeals court has upheld Folly Beach’s limit on short-term rental licenses, allowing the city to keep its cap of 800 vacation rental permits.
City leaders say the cap was approved by voters in 2023 with the goal of maintaining a balance between tourism and full-time residents on the island.
The decision comes after some property owners challenged the policy in court, arguing the cap prevented them from renting their homes short-term. However, the court sided with the city, ruling the policy regulates business licenses rather than zoning. That distinction was central to the legal challenge.
Mayor Chris Bizzell said the ruling reinforces the city’s approach to managing growth while protecting the community.
“The tourism numbers are basically the same,” Bizzell said. “What I have seen is we have a lot of people moving in that are now long-term residents, as opposed to looking at the community as an investment, which is great to have new families moving onto the island.”
The cap was created amid concerns that a growing number of homes were being used as vacation rentals instead of primary residences. At one point, nearly half of the homes on the island were operating as short-term rentals.
City leaders say the goal was to place guardrails around that growth and preserve Folly Beach’s residential character while still allowing tourism.
Bizzell said from the city’s perspective, the policy has not hurt the overall economy.
“Our hospitality tax numbers and our accommodations taxes are at or above historic levels,” he said.
Still, some local business owners say they are concerned about how limiting vacation rentals could affect spending on the island.
Perry Freeman, president of Perry Hospitality, said visitors staying in short-term rentals often spend several days dining, shopping, and supporting local businesses.
“It’s not necessarily just a cap on the rentals — it’s a cap on tourists,” Freeman said, explaining that visitors staying on the island typically spend money every day during their trip.
Freeman said he believes there are fewer people staying on the island compared to previous years, something he says businesses are starting to feel.
“You see less people out there’s definitely been an impact on our business,” he said.
While the court decision keeps the cap in place for now, the legal fight may not be over.
The property owners who filed the lawsuit say they may ask the court for a rehearing and could ultimately try to take the case to the South Carolina Supreme Court.
Meanwhile, city leaders say they plan to continue reviewing the policy as part of long-term strategic planning to ensure it maintains the balance between tourism and residents that voters supported.
FOLLY BEACH — Two owners of several island properties lost their court appeal that sought to declare the local short-term rental cap illegal by arguing it was a change in zoning laws that deprived them of renting a new property.Folly East Indian Co., which has five short-term rental licenses for properties along Folly Beach Road, filed suit and sought an injunction in January 2023 to stop enforcement of the cap that limits island short-term rental licenses to 800.The landlord and real estate development company, owned by ...
FOLLY BEACH — Two owners of several island properties lost their court appeal that sought to declare the local short-term rental cap illegal by arguing it was a change in zoning laws that deprived them of renting a new property.
Folly East Indian Co., which has five short-term rental licenses for properties along Folly Beach Road, filed suit and sought an injunction in January 2023 to stop enforcement of the cap that limits island short-term rental licenses to 800.
The landlord and real estate development company, owned by Folly Beach residents Richard D. Brendel and Michael J. Riffert, argued that the new limit changed the zoning of properties by not allowing owners to rent them.
The city has long maintained the referendum, which was written by a citizen and voted into law by 53 percent of island residents in 2023, was a business license change, not a zoning one. The S.C. Supreme Court previously ruled that zoning provisions cannot be enacted by the referendum process.
The lawsuit stemmed from the plaintiffs’ inability to rent one property in particular. Prior to the moratorium the city permitted them to build a house they intended to operate as an income-producing short-term rental. Because of pandemic-related delays, construction took longer than expected and the owners missed their window to get a short-term license before the cap was enacted.
The plaintiffs argued the cap took away their vested rights, which by state law protects a property owner from changes in zoning ordinances for two years and would have grandfathered in their ability to rent the property.
A Charleston County court disagreed. In an April 2024 ruling, Circuit Judge Paul Burch affirmed the referendum is not a zoning ordinance. As such, it does not infringe on property rights because it is a modification of business licenses.
A business license is not a vested right, the judge said.
The following month, Folly East Indian Co. filed an appeal with the S.C. Court of Appeals, which on Feb. 18 sided with the lower court.
The court’s unpublished opinion, which means it has no precedential value, said the ordinance “at issue only amended City’s business regulations to impose a cap on the number of issued short-term rental business licenses” and that it “did not amend City’s zoning ordinance, did not rezone any properties … and did not determine where any specific activities may occur.”
Island wide, rentals are still legal in every district and every residential unit is allowed to become a rental. The referendum solely regulates how many can get a business license to operate as such.
The plaintiffs argued the cap deprives them of the “economically viable use” of their property, “infringes upon its vested rights, and will interfere with Plaintiff’s reasonable, investment-backed expectations.”
Since the referendum was enacted limiting the coveted permits, homeowners who bought properties to rent short-term for income or as a way to pay for a beach home are now unable to do that. There’s no revenue to supplement mortgages, some involving multi-million-dollar purchases with high interest rates. Many have struggled to sell off their homes since.
The 800-unit cap applies exclusively to second homes, not primary residences. At the time of the vote, there were 1,125 rental properties on Folly Beach, which accounted for 43 percent of its housing stock. About 200 entries remain on the waiting list and, as of October, no one has made it off the waitlist.
Bijan Ghom with Saxton & Stump, who represented the plaintiffs, told The Post and Courier the opinion didn’t offer much analysis or directly address “several legal arguments” made on behalf of the plaintiffs.
“Since the Court did not select this matter for oral argument, it is even more difficult to read between the tea leaves, so to speak,” he said. “In any event, my client intends to file a petition for rehearing this week. If that is denied, we plan to petition the Supreme Court for review.”
Ghom noted there is another case at the trial level that also challenges the short-term cap from another legal argument.
“So, all in all, we are still hopeful we will prevail,” he said.
The city had no additional comment.
Mayor Chris Bizzell previously told The Post and Courier fine-tuning the referendum is part of the city’s 2026 strategic plan.
“I think the biggest thing that's happening is a couple of people have asked us to maybe look at the different proposals that were in the initial short-term rental language that was proposed by (previous) Mayor (Tim) Goodwin, and then go back through that, discuss why or why not we adopted some of those provisions,” Bizzell said.